A Terrible Take From Intellectual Takeout on Historical Sites

On May 30th, 2019, Intellectual Takeout posted this article, "Why Are We No Longer Visiting Our Nation's Historical Sites?" And the author puts the problem as largely a result of "changing tastes". The problem being that historical sites across the United States are seeing significant declines in visitors. This was written before the COVID-19 pandemic, and thus all thoughts in this article, and the IT article should be viewed from that lens.

Our visit to the Monticello Railway Museum, July 2019

To put it nicely, I find this article to be terribly written, with the goal of convincing certain groups of people that young people do not have an interest in history. And given the comments I’ve seen in a couple Facebook groups about it, it worked quite well. This is incredibly divisive, dangerous, and most importantly, wrong, and while I'm older than most of Generation Z now (I'm pushing 30), I'm hopeful that this site is a stark rebuke of this take.

A pic from our visit to the Illinois Railway Museum

This blog, and my presence on social media, and the dozens of others that cater to other parts of history is proof that younger generations definitely have an interest in history, including American history.

In fact, I would say that there is more of an interest in history now than in earlier times. We are seeing the younger generations come to grips with history in the United States in ways that simply haven't been done before. It is not a stretch in the slightest that many parts of history that have been taught in America are at best, whitewashed over, and at worst, wrong.

And for those young people that don’t seem to care about history, have you thought of any way to bring that history alive to them? Or is it simply easier to complain about the younger generations?

Our visit to the Hoosier Valley Railroad Museum

The issue I believe that many historical sites face is the ease of access to information, not an indifference of younger generations. I can read almost everything there is to know about the Civil War from my iPhone.

Some of you may say that visiting Gettysburg or other battle sites gives you a completely different perspective on the war than you could from reading about it, and that is absolutely true, but that’s also easier said than done for most of us. 

Gettysburg is a 1000 mile trip for me, and prohibitively expensive for many. Who has weeks of vacation time, and more importantly, disposable income for such a trip? Far too few of us.

Nothing is too far for JetLaggedJaff though

Unlike some comments I’ve seen, I do not intend to frame my argument in a generational context. There are many reasons why historic sites are seeing declining guests, and it is counterintuitive to place the blame solely on the supposed indifference of millennials.

I think that this is a problem of the Shifting-Baseline Syndrome, and by that I mean that statistics on visits to historical sites alone cannot be the only metric one uses to define whether younger generations have a taste for history. It is sad to see as many museums as there are deal with the effects of changing times and a decline in attendance, but I think this could be a teachable moment for these institutions to adapt to changing tastes, and find new ways of engaging generations, rather than assume that "the younger generations are not taught to respect history"

Thanks as always for reading!

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Abandoned Route 66 in McCook, IL

Image
Route 66, the iconic "Main Street of America," weaves through the heart of the United States, connecting communities and embodying the spirit of adventure. However, not all sections of this historic highway have stood the test of time. While much of the former US 66 is drivable in one way or another, especially in Illinois, there are some parts are not.  One of the first such roadblocks for would-be travelers heading from Chicago to Los Angeles via the Mother Road, now known as Joliet Road, comes just outside of Chicago in McCook, IL, where the former highway is closed between 55th St and East Ave, and has been for over two decades. (Link to the location on our Ghost Towns Map ) Image: Google Maps at 55th and Joliet Rd in McCook, IL The land that the quarry would eventually take over was part of Stinson Airport in the early days of Route 66, dating back to before 1930. ( Abandoned Airports map ). 1938 USGS Aerial Imagery The quarrying on the south side of the road would...
Read more

The Underwater Water Slide: Fly Over at Durinrell TikiBad

Image
Have you ever wished to experience being transferred from one pool of liquid to another via a pipe? Had you visited the Dutch water park known as Durinrell , also known as Tikibad before 2010, you would have had the chance. Half water slide, half war crime, this was a unique water slide that was filled to the brim with water, leaving riders completely submerged throughout the journey. Image:  XtremeRidesNL Known as the Fly Over was an underwater water slide, which is exactly how it sounds, and transported riders from one pool to another using the water as propulsion. Built in 1994, riders dove underwater to access the slide, using gravity to transport them upwards via the Communicating Vessels Principle . Riders would be completely underwater for about 15-20 seconds. This is how I imagine those 15-20 seconds felt like while riding the slide. The slide was built to drain water in five seconds or less in case a rider got stuck in the slide or had a medical emergency, but the threat...
Read more

Railroad Vocabulary: A List of Words and Phrases Used in the Industry - Updated February 2024

Image
As somebody who enjoyed watching trains, but was not an employee of the railroad industry ( at least growing up ), when I would interact with railfans and historians, there was often a lot of technical jargon that applied only to the railroad industry thrown back and forth that made it difficult for a newcomer to understand what they were talking about. For example, what is a dinky? It's actually a passenger train. This non-inclusive language seems to keep the loop closed to members of the community, and to uncouple (no pun intended) that technical jargon and help make it easier for people to communicate with people in the industry, I am creating a list of railroad vocabulary that I'm hoping will make the industry more transparent.  BNSF 2361 . Image: Matt Flores While I ultimately believe that such technical jargon has no place outside of perhaps technical communications between employees, I know quite well that I alone am not going to stop people from communicating in a non-i...
Read more